As tempting as it might be, when auto insurance coverage, you don’t wish to focus solely on worth. That’s as a result of the standard of the insurance coverage supplier will inform your expertise once you make a declare or wish to reap the benefits of nice cell instruments. Bottom line: All auto insurance coverage corporations aren’t created equal.

That mentioned, it’s doable to search out good auto insurance coverage corporations with low premiums and nice service. And right here, we’ve carried out the heavy lifting for you.

To decide auto insurance coverage charges, suppliers use an algorithm that adjustments yearly. That equation elements in new statistics on driving behaviors and buyer necessities that would decrease or enhance charges. Because charges are always altering, it may be tough to find out which insurance coverage supplier will provide you with the perfect worth.

To simplify your reasonably priced automotive insurance coverage procuring journey, we’ve put collectively a complete information to match among the greatest recognized insurance coverage suppliers and their affordability. Out of the highest 25 licensed auto insurance coverage suppliers, we’ve recognized the 5 auto insurance coverage corporations we like greatest for reasonable auto insurance coverage, which we assessment beneath.

We comply with a rigorous editorial coverage designed to maintain our writers and editors unbiased. Articles could reference merchandise from our companions, so right here’s extra info on

How we generate income

The Simple Dollar is an unbiased, advertising-supported writer and comparability service. The Simple Dollar is compensated in change for featured placement of sponsored services, or your clicking on hyperlinks posted on this web site. This compensation could impression how, the place and in what order merchandise seem. The Simple Dollar doesn’t embody all corporations or all obtainable merchandise.

Research methodology

At The Simple Dollar, we created the SimpleRating score system for our readers to match and higher perceive their choices whereas purchasing for auto insurance coverage. For the perfect low-cost automotive insurance coverage, we in contrast the highest 25 automotive insurance coverage suppliers, then rated all of them on a scale of 1 to five. We checked out reductions, protection choices, buyer satisfaction, help and accessibility, then calculated the general rating for every.

We additionally checked out respected specialists within the area, together with J.D. Power, AM Best, Consumer Reports and the Insurance Information Institute. These organizations measure buyer satisfaction and monetary power, two of crucial elements to think about when selecting an insurance coverage firm.

The greatest low-cost automotive insurance coverage suppliers of 2021

  • Best Overall: Amica Mutual
  • Best for Military Members: USAA
  • Best for Mobile Tools and Resources: State Farm
  • Best for Customer Service: Geico
  • Best for Discounts: Progressive
Company Why we like them Average full protection Average minimal protection
Amica Mutual Best general for automotive insurance coverage $1,378 $405
USAA Best automotive insurance coverage for navy members $1,225 $384
State Farm Best automotive insurance coverage for cell instruments $1,457 $539
Geico Best automotive insurance coverage for customer support $1,405 $433
Progressive Best automotive insurance coverage for reductions $1,509 $582

Data is from Bankrate, which makes use of Quadrant Information Services to investigate charges. Quoted charges are primarily based on a 40-year-old female and male driver with a clear driving file and good credit score.

Compare the most cost effective automotive insurance coverage corporations

Best general – Amica

We like Amica Mutual the greatest general for auto insurance coverage. While Amica isn’t the bottom in worth of the insurance coverage corporations we analyzed, we discovered them to be the perfect general.  Across the board, Amica earns high marks among the many scores we comply with.

If you’re solely our SimpleRating, Amica is the perfect you’re going to search out, in our opinion. We significantly love this firm’s variety of reductions (18) and buyer help (5 out of 5).

Add to that, it is without doubt one of the lowest in its common full protection, at $1,378 a yr; for common minimal protection, it’s $405, which can also be one of many lowest we discovered.

Best for navy members – USAA

USAA is our favourite for navy members in auto insurance coverage. If you’re a navy member or member of the family, the USAA auto insurance coverage is a wonderful alternative for its high quality and worth.

Not solely is USAA one of many lowest in common minimal premiums at $384 a yr, it’s truly the bottom of the automotive insurance coverage suppliers we analyzed for common full protection premiums, at $1,225 a yr.

That in itself is a tempting motive to decide on this service, however there are additionally the highest marks in satisfaction from J.D. Power, as properly greatest at school over at Consumer Reports, with a 5 out of 5 in satisfaction for claims, premiums, service and coverage assessment.

Best for cell instruments – State Farm

We significantly love State Farm’s cell instruments, together with their user-friendly app, which lets you entry your accounts, get roadside help and extra. There are additionally the Drive Safe & Save™ and Steer Clear® to encourage protected driving.


4.6 / 5.0

SimpleRating State Farm 4.6

In phrases of sheer dimension, State Farm owns that area fingers down, which could offer you peace of thoughts in case you are searching for depth in an organization. 

The Insurance Information Institute ranked this insurance coverage supplier No. 1 in auto insurance coverage direct premiums written in 2019, the latest yr obtainable. It holds 16% of the business’s market share, and there are a whopping 19,000 unbiased contractor brokers. Add to that, State Farm has aggressive premiums, one thing you may not anticipate from a large.

Best for customer support – GEICO

Geico is the greatest in customer support, in our estimation, partly as a result of it does properly in satisfaction for claims and repair (4 out of 5 for every) over at Consumer Reports.

Geico’s biggest power as a customer-oriented firm is its app, Geico Mobile. With this device, you possibly can personalize your alerts and entry your entire essential info.

This insurance coverage service has one in every of our highest SimpleScores for auto insurance coverage, at 4.8 out of 5. That’s partly due to its superior choices in reductions and protection choices. In phrases of common minimal protection, it presents one of many lowest we discovered.

Best for reductions – Progressive

We really feel Progressive is the greatest for automotive insurance coverage reductions, not a lot in quantity (we counted 13), however in high quality. Besides paying in full and being a protected driver, you can also get reductions for proudly owning your house and having steady insurance coverage.


4.2 / 5.0

SimpleRating Progressive 4.2

Progressive’s Snapshot device is one other good way to save cash. It charges your driving, monitoring issues like how usually you drive, should you slam on the brake or should you used your telephone whereas driving.

This firm’s protection choices are additionally a priceless discover. Among the 13 we discovered, there may be free pet harm protection that pays any veterinary payments in case your pets are injured in an auto accident.

Consider smaller insurance coverage corporations

Smaller insurance coverage corporations aren’t listed in our high picks as a result of restricted regional availability, however these corporations can present a decrease price in comparison with nationwide corporations. It’s essential to buy round inside corporations licensed in your state or area to search out the perfect charge. We discovered that drivers paid $1,043 as a median annual premium with Erie Insurance. This stacks up with suppliers akin to USAA and Geico. Below are examples of a full protection annual premium for a pattern of regional corporations.

Smaller regional service Average full protection premium
Erie $1,043
Main St. American Company $658
American National $716
Virginia Farm Bureau $968
Oregon Mutual Insurance $1,054
Home-Owners $938
Integrity $989
Countryway $1,170
Grange $962
Westfield National $1,114

Car Insurance Rate Data. Premiums are assuming a 30-year-old with good credit score who drives a 2017 Honda Civic.

Discounts and good habits that get monetary savings on automotive insurance coverage

While insurance coverage corporations observe a couple of issues which are exterior of your management, akin to your age or gender, there are different elements of your profile which you could alter. Smart purchasing for automotive insurance coverage is properly value your whereas, as a result of you’ll possible be rewarded once you qualify for reductions or once you change your conduct.

For instance, work on enhancing your driving and deal with enhancing your credit score rating. Also, taking full benefit of reductions might help you land cheaper automotive insurance coverage. Discounts can embody all the pieces from firm loyalty to utilizing autopay or paying for the complete yr prematurely.

[ More: Why Is My Auto Insurance Premium So High? ]

Car insurance coverage reductions are available in a wide range of varieties. There could also be automotive insurance coverage reductions to your age, in case you are a university pupil, work area, sort of automotive or your driving habits. Some of the reductions you possibly can anticipate once you’re searching for the perfect low-cost automotive insurance coverage embody:

  • Bundled insurance coverage
  • Autopay low cost
  • Pay prematurely
  • Paperless statements low cost
  • Good pupil
  • Senior
  • Military
  • Accident-free
  • Hybrid or electrical car
  • Defensive driver course accomplished
  • Anti-theft system
  • Garage parking
  • Anti-lock brakes
  • Airbags
  • Safety tools

Shop round

Save time by utilizing a web based quote device to get a fast snapshot of potential charges from a number of auto insurance coverage corporations directly. It additionally helps you keep away from worth optimization, the place charges are established not simply on how dangerous a driver is to insure but additionally on how a lot insurance coverage corporations assume they’re comfy paying. Getting new quotes usually is one of the simplest ways to keep away from worth optimization as a result of insurers can see how usually you store round and subsequently how possible they’re to lose you as a buyer.

Bundle insurance policies

Many automotive insurance coverage corporations will provide you with a reduction you probably have different insurance policies with them. The most typical insurance policies for bundling are dwelling and auto insurance coverage. However, you could get a break on low-cost insurance coverage should you use the identical supplier for all times, dwelling, auto or renters insurance coverage insurance policies. Bundled insurance policies are handy too; you’ll be coping with just one invoice and one firm. Keep in thoughts that each insurance coverage firm presents a distinct quantity of financial savings for coverage bundling.

Boost your deductible

Raising your deductible is an efficient transfer you probably have money stashed away to pay a better deductible in case of a crash. Factors akin to your age and driving file can even have an effect on how a lot elevating your deductible will truly prevent.

Drive a low-risk automotive

Luxury automobiles are all the time the costliest to insure. These automobiles additionally price much more to repair and are engaging targets for thieves. Family-friendly automobiles together with minivans, sedans and smaller SUVs price the least to insure. Their drivers are typically extra cautious and are easier to repair, finally creating fewer claims. Based on our analysis, the Honda Odyssey XL, Jeep Wrangler Sport and Subaru Outback 2.5i are the most cost effective automobiles to insure. All three automobiles have annual premiums of round $1,300.

Change your driving habits

If you get dashing tickets, your invoice will skyrocket. If you’ve had a clear driving file for years, you should have cheaper automotive insurance coverage. Driving much less is the only, best approach to change your driving habits. Many states have already outlawed texting and driving. Another good tip is to train persistence and are available to finish stops when needed. Tell your insurer about your new habits to obtain the perfect insurance coverage charges. Some insurance coverage suppliers supply in-car expertise that identifies protected driving habits, like State Farm’s Drive Safe and Save and Progressive’s Snapshot.

Maintain good credit score

Most automotive insurance coverage corporations have a look at your credit score rating to assist decide your charge. According to client advocacy group United Policyholders, a rock-bottom credit score rating might imply you’ll pay double, triple and even quadruple over somebody with an ideal credit score rating. This controversial observe is against the law in 4 states: California, Hawaii, Maryland and Massachusetts. If you don’t dwell in a kind of states, working to lift your credit score rating might help you get reasonably priced auto insurance coverage.

How can I hold my insurance coverage low-cost after an accident?

Your automotive insurance coverage charge will enhance after an accident. There isn’t a particular greenback quantity as a result of the speed enhance depends upon the severity of the accident, and who was at-fault. An accident you trigger will most likely outcome within the largest enhance. In most states, a automotive accident stays in your driving file for 3 to 5 years, after which period your insurance coverage charge will lower, barring different points.

However, there are a number of methods you possibly can keep away from the speed hike after an accident. First, see in case your insurance coverage supplier presents accident forgiveness. It’s normally offered as an add-on coverage, so it would enhance your charge considerably. But it may be a significant lifesaver should you get right into a minor crash.

If your automotive insurance coverage supplier presents a reduction for taking a defensive driving class, now could be the time to do it. You is perhaps shedding a claims-free low cost, so be sure to’re making the most of each low cost you qualify for. If you’re nonetheless going through an enormous charge enhance, take into account procuring round for a less expensive coverage from a distinct supplier.

What varieties of automotive insurance coverage protection do I actually need?

When you buy automotive insurance coverage, you’ll need to determine whether or not you wish to go for legal responsibility protection or full protection automotive insurance coverage. Full protection insurance coverage, which incorporates complete and collision protection, comes with a heftier price ticket than liability-only insurance coverage. If you took out a mortgage to pay to your automotive, you most likely don’t have a alternative — your lender would require proof of complete and collision protection. Dropping this protection normally isn’t a good suggestion in case your automotive is value a good sum of money.

There are conditions when opting just for legal responsibility is smart. For occasion, should you drive an older, paid-off car that doesn’t have a lot worth to anybody however you, holding solely legal responsibility protection can imply important financial savings. Comprehensive and collision protection may be overkill on an older automotive you drive sparingly.

[ See: Auto Insurance Quotes, Explained ]

Just as some coverages are completely needed, there are non-compulsory add-ons you could determine aren’t needed. A standard add-on to a automotive insurance coverage coverage is private harm safety, which pays your medical bills after a crash. If you’re making an attempt to maintain your invoice low, private harm protection most likely isn’t a sensible purchase so long as you have got an excellent medical health insurance plan — there could be an excessive amount of overlap between the 2 insurance policies.

There are additionally uninsured and underinsured motorist coverages, which get you off the hook after a crash the place the opposite driver is at fault however doesn’t carry sufficient (or any) insurance coverage and might’t afford to pay. Other add-ons pay for rental automobiles whereas your automotive is being fastened and for roadside help. As for different little add-ons, take into account skipping them. If you possibly can cowl the price of a rental (or borrow a automotive from a good friend when you’re in a jam), rental-car riders are pointless and an AAA membership is commonly a greater deal than roadside help protection you probably have an older car.

Minimum protection automotive insurance coverage

The state’s minimal protection requirement is normally the most cost effective automotive insurance coverage obtainable, however state minimal protection varies. For instance, Alaska requires drivers to have a coverage of fifty/100/25 at least authorized quantity, that means $50,000 for bodily harm per individual in an accident, $100,000 for bodily harm whole per accident and $25,000 for property harm. In distinction, California’s minimal is decrease than Alaska’s at 15/30/5.

[ Next: What Is My State’s Minimum Car Insurance Coverage? ]

Car insurance coverage FAQs

There are a number of methods you possibly can decrease your month-to-month premium for extra reasonably priced insurance coverage. Start by procuring round for quotes to discover a supplier who can give you the perfect insurance coverage charges. You can even go for a better deductible, which is able to decrease your month-to-month premium. Take benefit of reductions, like bundling your insurance policies or insuring a number of automobiles. And don’t overlook about your credit score rating — paying your payments on time and holding bank card balances low will enhance your rating, which is able to translate into cheaper insurance coverage charges. These elements can mix that can assist you get low price insurance coverage.

The sort of automotive insurance coverage you select depends upon your wants and the quantity of danger you’re keen to take. You aren’t required to have full-coverage automotive insurance coverage, but it surely does supply probably the most safety should you’re in an accident.

If you’re in a position to pay the upper premiums related to full-coverage insurance coverage, it’s most likely definitely worth the further cash. For instance, should you don’t have full-coverage insurance coverage and also you’re discovered at-fault for an accident that induced harm to another person, you can be answerable for paying their medical bills out-of-pocket.

There is not any single auto insurance coverage supplier that gives the most cost effective automotive insurance coverage charges for all drivers throughout the board. The most reasonably priced insurance coverage supplier will differ from individual to individual. Remember that insurance coverage corporations have a look at a wide range of elements when figuring out your charge, akin to your age, the automotive you drive, your zip code and your credit score rating.

Every state has a minimal protection requirement that drivers will need to have earlier than placing their automotive on the street. However, many individuals select to buy further protection on high of what’s required for much more safety. How a lot protection you buy depends upon your finances, and the way a lot danger you’re keen to take.

Too lengthy, didn’t learn?

Finding low-cost automotive insurance coverage is feasible with slightly effort. Know your state minimal insurance coverage necessities and store round. Keep in thoughts that high quality of the product and firm must be factored. Don’t rule out non-compulsory protection, even when it provides to the price of your car insurance coverage. Sometimes, the most cost effective automotive insurance coverage now can depart you with a giant restore invoice down the street should you don’t perceive what coverages are included in your coverage.

There are a number of different methods you may get the perfect automotive insurance coverage for reasonable. Look for reductions, akin to bundling your owners and auto insurance coverage insurance policies with the identical insurer and selecting to autopay your premiums. Also, a change in habits will be value your whereas financially, akin to enhancing your credit score rating.

We welcome your suggestions on this text and would love to listen to about your expertise with the automotive insurance coverage corporations we suggest. Contact us at with feedback or questions.

The SimpleRating makes it straightforward to match services featured right here on The Simple Dollar in a clear, open and trustworthy manner. We charge these services utilizing 5 elements and common them to calculate a single SimpleRating. For auto insurance coverage, we examine:

  • Discounts
  • Coverage choices
  • Support
  • Customer satisfaction
  • Accessibility

You can learn extra about every issue and the main points of every rating in our auto insurance coverage methodology. Use our scores and editorial suggestions as you store for the perfect auto insurance coverage that matches your protection wants.

Car insurance coverage charges:  We used insurance coverage charges from Quadrant Information Services. This contains analyzing 1000’s of charges from all 50 states that have been publicly sourced from 2019 insurer filings. Rates are primarily based on a 30-year-old male or feminine that had a clear driving file. Full Coverage premiums assumed a $500 collision and complete deductible, and we checked out those that had each good and poor credit score. These charges must be used to tell your automotive insurance coverage procuring course of, however your individual quote could differ.

Why do some manufacturers have totally different SimpleScores on totally different pages?

To make sure the SimpleRating is as useful and correct as doable, we developed distinctive standards for each class we examine at The Simple Dollar. Since most manufacturers supply a wide range of monetary options, their services will rating otherwise relying on what we’re scoring on a given web page.

However, it’s additionally doable for a similar product from the identical model to have a number of SimpleScores. For occasion, if we examine State Farm’s dwelling insurance coverage in keeping with our standards for the perfect dwelling insurance coverage, it scores a 3.8 out of 5. But after we examine State Farm in keeping with the factors for the perfect auto insurance coverage, it scores increased, because the options the corporate presents can differ by the kind of insurance coverage.


We seemed on the variety of reductions every firm presents — extra reductions imply a better rating.

Coverage Options

We awarded increased scores to the businesses which have probably the most protection choices.


We awarded increased scores to lenders with probably the most channels for buyer help.

Customer Satisfaction

We leveraged the J.D. Power 2019 Auto Insurance Satisfaction Study℠ to see how prospects rated their expertise with every firm. (If an organization wasn’t included in J.D. Power’s research, we skipped this facet and averaged the 4 remaining facet scores.)


We seemed on the degree of accessibility of every firm –– the extra sources they’ve the upper their rating.

Elizabeth is a contributor to The Simple Dollar, the place she critiques insurance coverage suppliers and insurance policies. She has greater than three years of expertise writing for high on-line insurance coverage and finance publications, together with Bankrate, and

Reviewed by

  • Courtney Mihocik

    Courtney Mihocik

    Loans Editor

    Courtney Mihocik is an editor at The Simple Dollar who focuses on private loans, pupil loans, auto loans, and debt consolidation loans. She is a former author and contributing editor to,, and elsewhere.

  • Nashalie Addarich

    Nashalie Addarich

    Insurance Editor

    Nasha Addarich is an editor at The Simple Dollar and a former lawyer who focuses on dwelling insurance coverage, auto insurance coverage, life insurance coverage, and financial savings. She is a former contributing editor to