Home Today The Best Home Insurance Companies in Florida of 2021

The Best Home Insurance Companies in Florida of 2021


The finest householders insurance coverage firm in Florida is a person choice, however normally, we discovered that State Farm is nice for house insurance coverage in Florida. When assessing house insurance coverage corporations, we checked out value, worth and customer support. But we’ll get into that in a bit.

America’s top-rated house insurance coverage

  • Policies beginning at simply $25/month
  • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
  • Zero trouble, zero paperwork

We comply with a rigorous editorial coverage designed to maintain our writers and editors impartial. Articles could reference merchandise from our companions, so right here’s extra info on

How we make cash

The Simple Dollar is an impartial, advertising-supported writer and comparability service. The Simple Dollar is compensated in alternate for featured placement of sponsored services, or your clicking on hyperlinks posted on this web site. This compensation could impression how, the place and in what order merchandise seem. The Simple Dollar doesn’t embody all corporations or all obtainable merchandise.

You would possibly surprise, how will you get a Florida house insurance coverage quote that has each enough protection and is reasonably priced?

While location within the state is clearly an enormous issue due to climate occasions like excessive wind and hurricanes, there are different issues that resolve your price, together with age of the house and the roof’s situation.

We’ve researched the highest six householders insurance coverage corporations and in contrast them utilizing our SimpleRating methodology that can assist you discover the correct firm and protection on your wants.


To arrive at our selections in house insurance coverage corporations, we reviewed protection choices, obtainable reductions, buyer satisfaction, assist and accessibility to make suggestions for the perfect house insurance coverage corporations in Florida. This permits us to create our SimpleRating.

We additionally referenced Bankrate, Insurance Information Institute, Consumer Reports, J.D. Power and different authoritative organizations to reach at our choices.

The finest householders insurance coverage in Florida of 2021

  • Great Overall: State Farm
  • Great for Damage Amount: USAA
  • Great for Bundling: Allstate
  • Great for Low Rates: Universal Property Casualty (UPC)
  • Great for Customer Service: St. Johns Insurance
  • Great Locally Based Provider: Florida Peninsula Insurance Co

Great total – State Farm

State Farm is a superb insurance coverage supplier for householders who desire a respected firm with good customer support, versatile coverages and low premiums.

State Farm is a nationwide insurance coverage firm with a long-established historical past of top-notch customer support. There are 19,000 impartial brokers, so you’ve got a great probability to discover a State Farm agent with the correct protection in your space.

State Farm’s precise insurance coverage charges differ by state and particular person scenario, however the firm presents a number of reductions to assist householders get monetary savings on their insurance coverage.

Additionally, State Farm stands out for its buyer evaluations. In J.D. Power’s 2020 U.S. Home Insurance Study, State Farm was rated 7 out of 24 for total buyer satisfaction. The firm has additionally confirmed monetary stability with an A++ score from A.M. Best.

Great for harm quantity – USAA

USAA obtained a few of the prime scores with Consumer Reports, together with 5 out of 5 for harm quantities and well timed funds, as a result of satisfaction from prospects in each classes.

USAA has trade commonplace protection choices like dwelling, private belongings, legal responsibility, lack of use, different constructions, house sharing and earthquake. And there are additionally military-specific perks for lively obligation and deployed members like protection for uniforms if misplaced or broken.

The firm ranks excessive amongst insurers for its buyer satisfaction. USAA earns prime marks from third-party surveyors for its communication, billing course of, claims, price of service and coverage choices. You can discover comparable perks and repair high quality with its different insurance coverage insurance policies like auto, life and extra area of interest insurance coverage like pet, small enterprise, journey or particular occasions.

Great for bundling – Allstate

Allstate’s bundling choices make it a robust selection. With auto, house and bike insurance coverage obtainable, you possibly can maximize your reductions.

Floridians wanting to economize have the nice alternative with Allstate. Discounts embody a ten% welcome low cost, 5% for establishing autopay and for being over the age of 55 and retired. You can even discover coverage reductions for remaining claim-free, putting in fireplace safety units, buying a brand new house, being a smoke-free house and having protecting options like storm shutters.

Allstate would possibly grant members 10% off an auto coverage and 25% off house premiums for bundling auto and residential insurance coverage. You can bundle your coverage with life insurance coverage as effectively at various reductions. We suggest calling an area agent for particular alternatives.

Florida’s finest regional house insurance coverage corporations

Great for low charges – Universal Property & Casualty

If you’re on the lookout for house insurance coverage reductions with quite a lot of choices, contemplate Universal Property & Casualty.


4.3 / 5.0

SimpleRating Universal Property & Casualty 4.3

Customer Satisfaction N/A

Despite being a subsidiary of the biggest insurance coverage supplier in Florida (Universal Insurance Holdings), Universal Property & Casualty’s on-line presence isn’t as sturdy as a few of the different corporations that dominate the Florida house insurance coverage market. However, it makes up for that by providing a few of the lowest charges relying in your particular circumstance.

Universal prides itself on its superior customer support, and it presents help from an actual individual. During occasions of pure catastrophe or disaster, Universal nonetheless permits policyholders to file claims 24/7 by rerouting them via an environment friendly automated system and having representatives reconnect with them.

Universal Property & Casualty could also be an awesome selection for Floridians who’re on a price range. The firm presents reductions for having house protecting tools, being claims-free, being a loyal buyer, having a brand new roof, bundling insurance policies, having windstorm-protective options, and being over the age of 65.

Great for customer support – St. John’s Insurance

St. Johns presents commonplace house insurance coverage, with restricted protection. However, the corporate stands out for its customized customer support and pleasant brokers.


2.3 / 5.0

SimpleRating St. John’s Insurance 2.3

Customer Satisfaction N/A

St. Johns is a privately held Florida firm that makes a speciality of house owner’s insurance coverage merchandise. In addition to house insurance coverage, St. Johns additionally sells apartment, landlord and private umbrella insurance coverage. We selected St. Johns as an awesome house insurance coverage supplier in Florida due to the highest notch customer support.

Though you possibly can count on a excessive stage of experience from an organization with such a specialised focus, policyholders are unable to learn from multi-policy reductions that bigger, extra diversified corporations can provide. However, St. Johns boasts an A score in monetary stability from Demotech, Inc., wonderful customer support and aggressive pricing for its insurance policies, making St. John a prime supplier of Florida house insurance coverage.

Great domestically primarily based supplier – Florida Peninsula Insurance

If you’re on the lookout for native protection, contemplate Florida Peninsula. The firm has good protection, wonderful monetary power and nice evaluations throughout the board.


3.3 / 5.0

SimpleRating Florida Peninsula Insurance 3.3

Customer Satisfaction N/A

Experience dealing with hurricane claims is a promoting level for Sunshine State property homeowners. Policyholders can file claims not simply by cellphone but additionally on-line and make the most of a sturdy studying heart on the corporate web site. AM Best provides Florida Peninsula an A on its Financial Strength Rating (FSR).

One potential downside is that the corporate serves “just about” each Florida metropolis, which doesn’t assure that protection is accessible in your space.

Average price of house owners insurance coverage in Florida

The common price of house owners insurance coverage premiums in Florida was $1,960, the Insurance Information Institute discovered for 2018, the latest 12 months for this information. That compares to the nationwide common of $1,249 for a similar 12 months.

(These figures are primarily based on the HO-3 house owner package deal coverage for owner-occupied dwellings, 1 to 4 household models. It gives all dangers protection (besides these particularly excluded within the coverage) on buildings and broad named-peril protection on private property, and is the most typical package deal written.)

Florida ranked second for common householders insurance coverage premiums, behind solely Louisiana. The lowest? It was Oregon at $706 a 12 months.

Rank State Average premium
1 Louisiana $1,987
2 Florida $1,960
3 Texas $1,955
4 Oklahoma $1,944
5 Rhode Island $1,630

Choosing a nationwide or an area Florida insurance coverage firm

Florida is one state particularly that has quite a lot of regional insurance coverage suppliers to select from, just like the Florida Peninsula Insurance Company, along with the standard big-name corporations like State Farm and Allstate.

Pros and cons of Florida house insurance coverage corporations

Pros Cons
Personalized service

Not obtainable in all places
Local entry Can provide extra dated expertise
Regional experience

Pros and cons of nationwide carriers

Pros Cons
Can present extra companies

Lack of regional protection
Usually has a higher service space More troublesome to obtain private help
Better expertise and development

Things to learn about house insurance coverage in Florida

Keep in thoughts that householders insurance coverage charges in Florida will likely be closely impacted by geographical location. Coastal areas of Florida may even see greater charges than inland areas as a result of elevated threat of hurricane harm. For instance, a property within the Keys might face a lot greater insurance coverage premiums than a metropolis situated in the midst of the state.

What sort of house insurance coverage protection do I would like in Florida?

Coastal insurance coverage companies could encourage particular protection for hurricane-related damages. Your insurance coverage agent may additionally suggest including flood insurance coverage to your coverage.

Hurricane insurance coverage in Florida

If you embody hurricane protection as a part of your Florida householders insurance coverage protection, you will have a typical deductible and a hurricane deductible. A hurricane deductible will solely apply for those who file a declare for hurricane-related harm.

Deductibles often price between 2% and 5% of the worth of your property. In Florida, you even have the choice to get a $500 deductible, however your annual premium could also be a lot greater. You must resolve for those who’d relatively pay a better price on an ongoing foundation, or take your possibilities and pay a better deductible earlier than reimbursements kick in if you file a declare.

Also, your agent could talk about with you “wind-driven rain.” Having this further line merchandise could shield you from rain that causes harm as a result of wind pushed it in a gap.

Flood insurance coverage in Florida

Although flood insurance coverage doesn’t are available a typical coverage, including it to your coverage in states like Florida is standard.

Flood insurance coverage could shield you within the occasion of water overflow triggered from issues like hurricanes, landslides and earthquakes.

[ Read more: Understanding Your Homeowners Insurance Declarations Page ]

Florida house insurance coverage necessities 

Home insurance coverage isn’t required in Florida, however your mortgage lender should require some type of it till your house’s mortgage is paid off to assist cowl your mortgage.

Even although house insurance coverage isn’t required, many go for it in case the surprising occurs. Your coverage protection will help cowl restore prices if there’s ever a break-in or extreme storm. Overall, house insurance coverage would possibly cowl property harm, belongings and repairs in particular conditions.

Types of house insurance coverage insurance policies in Florida 

There are several types of house insurance coverage for Florida residents. Your coverage will depend on your house’s construction and your private wants. Some insurance policies will cowl the house’s construction, whereas different insurance coverage selections have a number of exceptions. It’s finest to talk along with your insurer to seek out the perfect protection on your Florida house.

Mobile house: Mobile house insurance coverage protects a manufactured or cell house from harm. Most cell house insurance policies additionally cowl your valuables. If your insurer doesn’t provide cell house insurance coverage then dwelling insurance coverage protection is another that may cowl your house and belongings.

Renters: Renters insurance coverage can cowl the tenant’s belongings and legal responsibility, however this coverage doesn’t often cowl harm to the rental house, townhouse or apartment.

Dwelling kind: A dwelling kind is often included in your house owner’s insurance coverage. It can cowl harm in areas which are hooked up to your house corresponding to a deck or hooked up storage. This kind covers dangers or different areas of your house that aren’t already included in your coverage.

Owner-occupied: This insurance coverage is usually for an proprietor’s main single-family house. Owner-occupied insurance coverage is healthier generally known as “homeowner’s insurance” to cowl the house construction and valuables listed within the coverage.

Condo unit: Condo homeowners often get apartment insurance coverage to cowl what your householders affiliation (HOA) gained’t cowl together with unit damages, legal responsibility and stolen valuables.

Florida house insurance coverage FAQs

Home insurance coverage in Florida just isn’t necessary, however mortgage lenders could require it. You agent could suggest house insurance coverage If you’re going to dwell in Florida the place the chance of pure catastrophe is excessive.

Under a alternative price householders coverage, your house is roofed for the quantity it will price to switch your house and residential contents at present prices. Under an precise money worth coverage, your house is roofed for alternative price minus depreciation.

Most commonplace insurance policies don’t embody protection from hurricanes or different pure disasters. Speak along with your insurance coverage agent about including protection to be sure you have safety from the disasters probably to occur in your space.

Home insurance coverage charges in Florida are primarily based on a number of components, and every insurer has totally different protection choices at totally different charges. As you store round you’ll discover that almost all charges have in mind the house’s location, age, building and sq. footage. You may additionally get credit score for programs that assist scale back harm corresponding to a professionally monitored safety system to scale back the chance of theft.

America’s top-rated house insurance coverage

  • Policies beginning at simply $25/month
  • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
  • Zero trouble, zero paperwork

Too lengthy, didn’t learn?

In a state like Florida the place tropical storms, hurricanes and flooding can wreak havoc, your agent could suggest house insurance coverage to guard your house and belongings. Be certain to analysis your choices to seek out the perfect protection on your neighborhood in Florida. And bear in mind that Florida house insurance coverage quotes could be greater than in different states, however we have now some tips about issues that may enable you decrease the price of your house insurance coverage coverage.

We welcome your suggestions on this text and would love to listen to about your expertise with the house insurance coverage corporations we suggest. Contact us at inquiries@thesimpledollar.com with feedback or questions.

The SimpleRating is a proprietary scoring metric we use to objectively evaluate services at The Simple Dollar.

For each evaluate, our editorial crew:

  • Identifies 5 measurable features to check throughout every model
  • Determines the score standards for every facet rating
  • Averages the 5 facet scores to supply a single SimpleRating

Here’s a breakdown of the 5 facet scores and their score standards for our evaluations on house insurance coverage.

Why do some manufacturers have totally different SimpleScores on totally different pages?

To make sure the SimpleRating is as useful and correct as attainable, we developed distinctive standards for each class we evaluate at The Simple Dollar. Since most manufacturers provide a wide range of monetary options, their services will rating otherwise relying on what we’re scoring on a given web page.

However, it’s additionally attainable for a similar product from the identical model to have a number of SimpleScores. For occasion, if we evaluate State Farm’s house insurance coverage in response to our standards for the perfect house insurance coverage, it scores a 3.8 out of 5. But after we evaluate State Farm in response to the standards for the perfect auto insurance coverage, it scores greater, because the options the corporate presents can differ by the kind of insurance coverage.


We appeared on the variety of reductions every firm presents – extra reductions imply a better rating.

Coverage Options

We awarded greater scores to the businesses that supply extra protection choices.


We awarded greater scores to corporations with essentially the most channels for buyer assist.

Customer Satisfaction

We leveraged the J.D. Power 2019 Home Insurance Satisfaction Study℠ to see how prospects rated their expertise with every firm. (If an organization wasn’t included in J.D. Power’s research, we skipped this facet and averaged the 4 remaining facet scores.)


We appeared on the stage of accessibility of every firm – the extra assets they’ve the upper their rating

Lauren Ward is a private finance author dwelling in Virginia’s Blue Ridge Mountains together with her husband and three youngsters. In her spare time she enjoys board video games and gardening.

Reviewed by

  • Courtney Mihocik

    Courtney Mihocik

    Loans Editor

    Courtney Mihocik is an editor at The Simple Dollar who makes a speciality of private loans, pupil loans, auto loans, and debt consolidation loans. She is a former author and contributing editor to Interest.com, PrivateLoans.org, and elsewhere.