Planning to file a declare along with your auto insurance coverage supplier? Whether you’re submitting for a totaled automotive or accident, submitting a declare can include a considerable enhance in premium charges. Here are a couple of essential factors to contemplate when submitting a declare.

According to InsuranceQuotes, the typical enhance within the U.S. is between 34% and 41% for somebody with full protection that features collision and state-mandated legal responsibility prices. For instance, when you’ve got a clear driving document and your annual premium is $1,555, when you file an at-fault accident declare, your premium may enhance to $2,090 or extra based mostly on the place you reside.

Furthermore, a joint examine between InsuranceQuotes and Quadrant Information Services reveals {that a} single auto declare can result in important premium will increase. Additionally, premium will increase have risen incrementally over the previous few years.

Insurance fee results after an accident

The enhance you may anticipate to see in your insurance coverage premiums after an at-fault accident varies by location, driving document, automobile and the insurance coverage firm. Upon reviewing the info beneath, we discovered that drivers ought to anticipate wherever from a 23% to 73% enhance in premiums in yr one after an at-fault accident.

Here are some typical post-accident insurance coverage charges within the first yr following an at-fault accident with fashionable U.S. automotive insurance coverage firms:

Company Average Premium After At-Fault Accident % Change in Average Premium After At-Fault Accident
$2,174 per yr / $181 per 30 days
$2,226 per yr / $185 per 30 days
$2,772 per yr / $231 per 30 days
Liberty Mutual
$2,358 per yr / $196 per 30 days
State Farm
$1,617 per yr / $134 per 30 days
$1,997 per yr / $166 per 30 days
3,017 per yr / $251 per 30 days

Progressive is available in because the insurance coverage firm with charges most affected by an at-fault accident inside the first yr after the accident, with a whopping 73% premium enhance. State Farm, with a 23% premium enhance, is available in because the insurance coverage firm with charges least affected by an at-fault accident.

Insurance fee results by state

While the numbers present your charges may surge after an accident no matter the place you reside, some states report costlier will increase than others. As the InsuranceQuotes examine famous, the next 5 states reported the most important premium will increase after a single auto declare price $2,000 or extra:

  • California: 63.1% enhance
  • New Hampshire: 60.3% enhance
  • Texas: 59.9% enhance
  • Massachusetts: 57.3% enhance
  • North Carolina: 57.3% enhance

States with the bottom premium will increase after an identical declare included:

  • Maryland: 21.5% enhance
  • Michigan: 26.1% enhance
  • Oklahoma: 27.9% enhance
  • Montana: 30.2% enhance
  • Kentucky: 30.6% enhance

Experts who commented on the examine blame the broad swings in premium will increase on the truth that insurance coverage laws largely differ by state. In California, for instance, voters handed a proposition in 1988 that restricted the elements insurance coverage firms may use to set auto charges. Because California insurance coverage premiums from that time ahead may solely be based mostly on driving document, common miles pushed and years of expertise, it’s solely pure for at-fault claims to trigger premiums to burst.

In Maryland, insurance coverage firms can base premiums on elements together with gender, age, occupation, credit score rating and marital standing. The state’s broader base of guidelines for insurance coverage firms could punish single younger males with a bad credit score whether or not they’re good drivers or not, but it surely’s seemingly the rationale Maryland reported the bottom after-accident premium surges of any state.

Car insurance coverage charges after an accident, defined

How lengthy will my fee be greater?

Increases in your insurance coverage premium can final so long as three to 5 years after an at-fault accident if damages to your automobile exceed over $2,000. Rates differ, with some insurers charging far more than others.

How to decrease your charges

While you may’t change the accident after it’s occurred, there are a couple of steps you may take to attempt to scale back your premium:

  • Ask about accident forgiveness: This is a proactive tip as an alternative of a reactive one, however when searching for automotive insurance coverage ask insurance coverage suppliers if they’ve an accident forgiveness apply. Not all firms provide this, however those who do gives you one at-fault accident with no enhance in premium when you match sure standards.
  • Consider your deductible: Insurance premiums and insurance coverage deductibles have an inverse relationship. When you choose a decrease deductible, it ends in the next premium. When you choose the next deductible, it ends in a decrease premium. If your premiums go up after an at-fault accident, contemplate rising your deductible (if reasonably priced) to lower your annual premium.
  • Avoid submitting claims for small issues: Insurance firms assess your premiums based mostly on the monetary threat you pose to the corporate. More claims can imply extra payouts for the insurance coverage supplier. If you’ve just lately filed a declare on an at-fault accident, don’t submit different claims for smaller issues for some time.

    Shop round. As you noticed from the info we collected above, the chances of enhance to premiums after an at-fault accident differ significantly by firm. It by no means hurts to get some quotes from different suppliers.
  • Increase your credit score rating. This received’t be a direct profit as rising a credit score rating can take a while. However, insurance coverage suppliers appear to supply higher premiums to these with credit score scores larger than 600.

[ Read: When Should You Downgrade Your Car Insurance? ]

Which claims enhance your charges probably the most?

Not surprisingly, the InsuranceQuotes examine concludes that bodily damage claims could cause your premiums to spike probably the most.

“Bodily injury claims are filed whenever a driver causes injuries to individuals as the result of an accident,” notes the press launch. “And because they are often so costly, every state except New Hampshire requires drivers to obtain a minimum amount of coverage for these circumstances.”

As the numbers present, a single bodily damage declare will end in a mean premium enhance of 48.6%. However, some states reported bigger premium hikes after bodily damage claims, together with California (73.2%), New Hampshire (65.9%), North Carolina (65.9%), Texas (64.8%) and Massachusetts (62.3%).

Comprehensive auto claims resulted within the least important premium will increase total. Unlike bodily damage claims which can lead to important medical payments, complete claims embrace situations like getting dangerous gasoline in your automotive, hitting a deer or having a tree fall in your automotive.

In every of those instances, the prices are often insignificant. Still, the typical premium enhance after a complete declare was 2% nationally throughout the board. Only Nebraska (10.6%), Louisiana (9.7%), Minnesota (7.1%), Wisconsin (6.9%) and Iowa (6.8%) reported will increase a lot greater than common.

[ Next: Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies ]

What if the accident wasn’t my fault?

If your insurance coverage firm doesn’t provide accident forgiveness, whether or not or not your charges will enhance after an accident through which you weren’t at fault is insurance coverage supplier particular. Some suppliers won’t enhance your premium if this was your first accident, however when you’ve got a number of accidents, even in case you are not at fault, it may end in an elevated premium.

Your supplier seems to be at how dangerous you might be to insure. If you have got an at-fault accident, you’re a greater threat. If you have got one not-at-fault accident, you is probably not perceived as greater threat. But when you’ve got a number of not-at-fault accidents, that may enhance your perceived threat stage with the insurance coverage supplier since you are driving in high-risk for accident conditions, whether or not you’re at fault or not.

The backside line is, when you are higher off to have a not-at-fault accident, any accident in any respect could enhance your auto insurance coverage charges.

Frequently requested questions

The Insurance Information Institute present in its More Accidents, Larger Claims Drive Costs Higher examine that from Q1 2014 to Q1 2016, auto insurance coverage went up with the next losses by:

  • Bodily damage: 9.6%
  • Property harm: 14.7%
  • Personal damage safety: 18.4%
  • Collision: 11.1%
  • Comprehensive: 11.0%

Your automotive insurance coverage premium can go down for a number of causes:

  • In some states, as you strategy 25, your premium can go down.
  • If your credit score rating will increase, it could possibly have an effect on your premium positively.
  • Your alternative in automotive (age, make and mannequin) can decrease your fee.
  • If you drive much less, it could possibly decrease your fee.
  • If you haven’t had a declare in a sure variety of years, that may decrease your premium.

You ought to at all times inform your insurer when you have been concerned in an accident. No matter how minor, not reporting an accident can lead to greater prices that may exceed greater premium charges. If the opposite driver sues you, your insurer can refuse to honor your coverage, which implies that you’ll be accountable for all authorized payments within the plaintiff’s favor. 

It is greatest to instantly report an accident, do your analysis and ask your agent about your choices. If your insurer should increase your premium, you may store round for a brand new coverage, enhance your deductible, search for reductions and enroll in a driving course.

Too lengthy, didn’t learn?

Although the typical enhance for submitting a declare is at 31% to 41%, submitting doesn’t at all times end in rising premiums. Several various factors decide the influence in your premium, like location, your insurance coverage firm, your protection particulars and extra. Although submitting a declare can lead to the next premium, it’s at all times greatest to report an accident to your insurer to stop surprising expenses.

We welcome your suggestions on this text. Contact us at with feedback or questions.

Holly Johnson is a frugality knowledgeable and award-winning author who’s obsessive about private finance and getting probably the most out of life. A lifelong resident of Indiana, she enjoys gardening, studying, and touring the world together with her husband and two kids. In addition to The Simple Dollar, Holly writes for well-known publications similar to U.S. News & World Report Travel, PolicyGenius, Travel Pulse, and Frugal Travel Guy. Holly additionally owns Club Thrifty.

Reviewed by

  • Nashalie Addarich

    Nashalie Addarich

    Insurance Editor

    Nasha Addarich is an editor at The Simple Dollar and a former lawyer who focuses on dwelling insurance coverage, auto insurance coverage, life insurance coverage, and financial savings. She is a former contributing editor to