Among the house insurance coverage corporations serving New Jersey, we discovered Amica Mutual to be nice general. And we picked 4 others that do a terrific job as nicely for his or her totally different causes. Using SimpleRating and our proprietary methodology, our staff evaluated the highest 5 insurance coverage suppliers in New Jersey to assist simplify your procuring expertise.

America’s top-rated house insurance coverage

  • Policies beginning at simply $25/month
  • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
  • Zero trouble, zero paperwork

We observe a rigorous editorial coverage designed to maintain our writers and editors unbiased. Articles could reference merchandise from our companions, so right here’s extra data on

How we make cash

The Simple Dollar is an unbiased, advertising-supported writer and comparability service. The Simple Dollar is compensated in trade for featured placement of sponsored services, or your clicking on hyperlinks posted on this web site. This compensation could affect how, the place and in what order merchandise seem. The Simple Dollar doesn’t embody all corporations or all obtainable merchandise.

Our methodology

Using our proprietary scoring system, known as SimpleRating, we assessed the highest house insurance coverage corporations. We checked out obtainable reductions, protection choices, buyer satisfaction, accessibility and high quality of help.

We additionally checked out different respected reviewers, resembling J.D. Power, which tracks buyer satisfaction every year, and Consumer Reports, which appears to be like at such elements as satisfaction in coverage opinions, claims, and different parts of selecting nice house insurance coverage.

The greatest householders insurance coverage in New Jersey

  • Great Overall: Amica Mutual
  • Great for Coverage Add-ons: Allstate
  • Great for Affordability: NJM Insurance
  • Great for Claims Processing: State Farm
  • Great for Policy Management: Plymouth Rock Assurance

Great general – Amica

With a broad vary of protection choices, distinctive reductions and excessive buyer satisfaction, the one query you’ll have about Amica Mutual is, “Where do I sign up?”

From affordability and protection choices to obtainable reductions and buyer satisfaction, Amica Mutual gives nice general householders insurance coverage protection in New Jersey.

Great for protection add-ons – Allstate

Leave nothing left to likelihood with the strong protection add-ons obtainable at Allstate.

Allstate gives New Jersey residents with a number of the most unusual and complete protection add-ons, permitting them to guard all of their belongings — yup, even the tennis racket.

Great in affordability – NJM Insurance

Who stated householders’ insurance coverage in New Jersey needed to value an arm and a leg? NJM Insurance makes defending your property straightforward and inexpensive.


4.2 / 5.0

SimpleRating NJM Insurance 4.2

Offering nice inexpensive householders’ insurance coverage merchandise, NJM Insurance is a robust choice for New Jersey residents. But it doesn’t cease there, NJM additionally gives loads of protection choices and huge reductions to make your property insurance coverage much more inexpensive.

Great in claims processing – State Farm

If you’re in search of a staff of precise people to assist course of your declare, State Farm is unquestionably the insurance coverage provider you want to your New Jersey house.

What State Farm lacks in protection add-ons and reductions, they greater than make up for with wonderful customer support and superior claims-management providers. State Farm not solely gives you with nice insurance coverage, however its web site gives private finance instruments that will help you make good cash strikes.

Great in coverage administration – Plymouth Rock Assurance

Don’t let their hyper-local outward look idiot you: Plymouth Rock has a number of the most streamlined instruments obtainable for policyholders to handle their insurance policies like a professional.


3.6 / 5.0

SimpleRating Plymouth Rock Assurance 3.6

Plymouth Rock Assurance makes coverage administration a breeze with easy on-line instruments designed to simplify claims submitting, invoice pay, and extra. You also can obtain its app to handle your coverage and file claims. If you might be in search of a neighborhood provider that understands precisely what you want in New Jersey, Plymouth is a superb choice.

America’s top-rated house insurance coverage

  • Policies beginning at simply $25/month
  • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
  • Zero trouble, zero paperwork

Choosing your supplier

Before choosing your property insurance coverage supplier in New Jersey, you’ll must conduct thorough analysis on each nationwide and native carriers. While nationwide carriers would possibly supply a wider vary of protection choices, native and regional suppliers could have insurance policies which can be higher tailor-made to your particular location. In some instances, the coverage you discover from a neighborhood or regional supplier could even be cheaper than carriers that supply merchandise nationwide.

Local provider


  • Can be cheaper than nationwide suppliers.
  • Offers protection choices which can be particular to your space.
  • Build a private relationship together with your insurance coverage agent.


  • May not at all times have the protection choices you want to your house.
  • May not have as many obtainable reductions so that you can make the most of.

National provider


  • Offers a broader vary of protection choices.
  • Provides many reductions for householders.
  • Offers on-line, cell and 24/7 instruments for patrons.


  • Less private customer support.
  • May pay extra for protection choices particular to your area.

New Jersey’s minimal insurance coverage necessities

Any individual that owns a house in New Jersey and funds the house by means of a lender is required to own a householders’ insurance coverage coverage. Some lenders could solely require the house owner to hunt protection for the mortgage quantity. If you’re looking for alternative value protection, your lender would possibly require you to insure your property for a set restrict.

The quantity of insurance coverage required in New Jersey relies in your property’s worth, and householders additionally want to make sure they’ve sufficient private legal responsibility protection to guard them from claims that others could file in opposition to them.

Flood protection

The common annual rainfall in New Jersey is 46 inches — a whopping 1’2” greater than the U.S. nationwide common. All that water has to go someplace, and it’d simply be your basement. That’s why it’s a fantastic concept for New Jersey residents to think about including flood insurance coverage to their insurance policies. Most customary insurance policies don’t embody flood protection, so it’s necessary to discover a provider that provides this as an add-on when researching the most effective house insurance coverage supplier to your New Jersey house.

Hurricane protection

When folks consider hurricane season, they usually consider Florida, Louisiana, or Texas because the nation’s hotspots. But New Jersey experiences a reasonably energetic hurricane season as nicely. In reality, 2020 was a record-setting 12 months for hurricanes within the state, and these numbers are solely anticipated to extend, in accordance with Colorado State University’s Department of Atmospheric Science.

That stated, hurricane protection is a worthwhile funding — particularly in case your Jersey house occurs to be alongside the shoreline. Be certain to discover a supplier that provides hurricane protection as an add-on to their obtainable insurance policies.

How a lot does house insurance coverage value in New Jersey?

The value of house insurance coverage in New Jersey is as common as they arrive. According to the Insurance Information Institute, the typical annual premium for householders’ insurance coverage in New Jersey is $1,192 — simply $19 beneath the nationwide common. However, householders can anticipate to pay roughly relying on the next:

  • Property Value
  • Replacement Cost
  • Age of Home
  • Roof Condition
  • Claims History
  • Credit History
  • Proximity to Body of Water

Even the kind of canine you’ve gotten, whether or not or not your property has a swimming pool and your marital standing can issue into your ultimate price. One of the best methods to lower your premium is by rising your deductible. Even a small enhance from $500 to $1,000 may also help you save as a lot as 25% in your insurance coverage premium.

America’s top-rated house insurance coverage

  • Policies beginning at simply $25/month
  • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
  • Zero trouble, zero paperwork

New Jersey house insurance coverage FAQs

While there aren’t any set necessities for a way a lot insurance coverage you want in New Jersey, it’s a good suggestion to have protection that matches or exceeds the worth of your property. Assess your property’s worth completely earlier than looking for protection so you know the way a lot you want to your coverage.

If you’re a New Jersey resident and also you personal a house that’s financed by means of a lender, you might be required to have householders’ insurance coverage. The kind and breadth of protection will doubtless be specified by your lender so as so that you can obtain a mortgage. If you paid money to your house, you aren’t required to have a house insurance coverage coverage. However, it’s a wise solution to defend your property within the occasion they incur unexpected harm.

Even although New Jersey is the tenth-most costly state to stay in America, householders insurance coverage is one expense that’s shockingly common for state residents. With a mean annual premium costing simply $1,192, New Jersey’s house insurance coverage charges fall $19 beneath the nationwide common.

Too lengthy, didn’t learn?

There are loads of insurance coverage suppliers to select from as a New Jersey resident, however our staff thinks Amica Mutual is your best option obtainable within the Garden State. However, we perceive that everybody is totally different and has distinctive wants, which is why we encourage all our readers to conduct thorough analysis to seek out the coverage that works greatest for them. Consider your choices by way of nationwide and native suppliers, evaluate add-on coverages and make the most of obtainable reductions so you may get the most effective house insurance coverage coverage to your New Jersey house.

For extra data relating to protection and coverage choices to your house, try our Guide to Home Insurance.

We welcome your suggestions on this text and would love to listen to about your expertise with the insurers we advocate. Contact us at with feedback or questions.

The SimpleRating is a proprietary scoring metric we use to objectively evaluate services at The Simple Dollar.

For each evaluate, our editorial staff:

  • Identifies 5 measurable features to match throughout every model
  • Determines the ranking standards for every side rating
  • Averages the 5 side scores to provide a single SimpleRating

Here’s a breakdown of the 5 side scores and their ranking standards for our opinions on house insurance coverage.

Why do some manufacturers have totally different SimpleScores on totally different pages?

To make sure the SimpleRating is as useful and correct as doable, we developed distinctive standards for each class we evaluate at The Simple Dollar. Since most manufacturers supply a wide range of monetary options, their services will rating in a different way relying on what we’re scoring on a given web page.

However, it’s additionally doable for a similar product from the identical model to have a number of SimpleScores. For occasion, if we evaluate State Farm’s house insurance coverage in accordance with our standards for the most effective house insurance coverage, it scores a 3.8 out of 5. But after we evaluate State Farm in accordance with the factors for the most effective auto insurance coverage, it scores greater, because the options the corporate gives can fluctuate by the kind of insurance coverage.


We regarded on the variety of reductions every firm gives – extra reductions imply a better rating.

Coverage Options

We awarded greater scores to the businesses that supply extra protection choices.


We awarded greater scores to corporations with probably the most channels for buyer help.

Customer Satisfaction

We leveraged the J.D. Power 2019 Home Insurance Satisfaction Study℠ to see how prospects rated their expertise with every firm. (If an organization wasn’t included in J.D. Power’s examine, we skipped this side and averaged the 4 remaining side scores.)


We regarded on the stage of accessibility of every firm – the extra sources they’ve the upper their rating

Carly Severino is a contract copywriter and editor with greater than 15 years of writing expertise and is the present founding father of Word Nerd Writing & Editing Services. Specializing in content material advertising and search engine optimisation, she is adept at serving to companies meet their aims by means of strategic planning and flawless copy.

Reviewed by

  • Nashalie Addarich

    Nashalie Addarich

    Insurance Editor

    Nasha Addarich is an editor at The Simple Dollar and a former legal professional who makes a speciality of house insurance coverage, auto insurance coverage, life insurance coverage, and financial savings. She is a former contributing editor to